Its not that the book wasn't well written. Its also not that it was filled with naughty stuff. Those are two things that will definitely ruin a book for me, this one was extremely well written and would probably be rated PG-13 for some language, sexual content and innuendo. The thing that made this book impossible for me to highly recommend is the feeling it left me with.
I am an emotional reader, so I tend to take on the attitude of a lot of what I read. For example, Twilight made me as giddy as a school girl, which is one of the reasons I liked it so much. I felt good, happy, and madly in love with the man of my dreams. The Goose Girl, perhaps my favorite book ever, makes me feel excited about new adventures and like I can accomplish anything every time I read it. Some books have little to no effect on me emotionally, these books are generally given 1 (or 2 stars at most) because I think the job of the author is to get me to feel something.
Ms. Binchy was a super storyteller. She had me feeling emotions throughout the whole book, but toward the end I was too filled with distrust and suspicion to really like the book as a whole.
Its the story of a family living in a small town built around a lake in Ireland. The mother of the family married the father because she'd been left by the one she really loved and so she tells him when she marries him that she won't ever really love him the way he wants her to. They have 2 kids and when they are 12 and 9 (I think) the mom disappears. Everyone knew she was unhappy, so its not terribly surprising to the small town. Although, it is very sad. The main character is the daughter in the family. And it covers about 6 years of life.
The story is interesting. Its written in short spurts of different happenings in many people's lives. You will not get bored reading it, though its possible to get confused. I had a hard time with many of the characters because they were so immoral. It seemed like everyone was making choices that were purely selfish. The town is pretty much all Catholic, yet very few behave in accordance with those beliefs or standards. As I read on, I found myself thinking, 'Is this what people in the world are really like?!' I like to believe that a majority of people know right from wrong and follow through with it. Maybe I'm naive, but even if I am, I prefer to shield myself from books that are filled with things so contrary to who I am. That is why I had to give this book only 2 stars. It would have been 1 if I hadn't enjoyed the first portion so much, its just that yucky feeling that I still feel clinging to my thoughts, that disappointment I feel in the characters giving way so easily to the natural man.






